Early graphic reports
Art Spiegelman’s Maus (1986/1991) is surely the most frequently cited and most thoroughly analyzed work in comics research, translated into dozens of languages and arguably the most important genre-defining work of Holocaust comics. It is symptomatic of an ongoing interest in the function of photographs for documenting horror and constructing a memory culture, but it also foregrounds the relative oversight of another, equally relevant, visual source: drawings by people imprisoned by the Nazis in ghettos and detained in camps, who either died there or narrowly escaped death. As Ole Frahm showed in his monograph Genealogie des Holocaust (2006), Spiegelman bases several of his panels set in Auschwitz on the few surviving photographs of this death camp (though he does not use any Nazi photographs), but he also cites the drawings of Alfred Kantor. Kantor initially made these drawings in Auschwitz and redrew them shortly after liberation in the displaced persons camp because he had been forced to destroy his original drawings for his own protection: “I drew the pictures in this book at a displaced persons’ camp in Deggendorf, Bavaria. I had come there in July of 1945, ten weeks after having been liberated from three and a half years of imprisonment in three Nazi concentration camps,” writes Alfred Kantor – born in Prague in 1923 and deported first to Theresienstadt, then to Auschwitz, and later to Schwarzheide – in the introduction to The Book of Alfred Kantor (1971).
One aim of our work in the Centre is to establish the starting points of a genealogy of graphic Holocaust depictions that begins with the drawings from ghettos and camps and created in hiding. As the first visual depictions of the persecution of Jewish people and others defined as “inferior” by the Nazis, these drawings can be considered both a starting point and intervention into the genesis of the Holocaust's visual memory within the medium of graphic narrative. Their dual temporality stems from the fact that the drawings by Alfred Kantor, René Baumer, Zsuzsa Merényi, Hans Rosenthal, and Helga Weissová (and many others) were created either before the end or directly after the end of the Second World War. They are thus contemporary testimonies that cannot rely on an already consolidated repertoire of images or an established narrative of events. On the other hand, they were published only after 1945 (and in some cases much later) and, through their paratextual framing and historical contextualization, simultaneously act as interventions into an ongoing historicization and memory-culture processing of the Holocaust.
The question to be posed about this material is also (at least) a dual one. On the first level, it must be clarified historically how the respective depictions came into being, under what conditions they were created, what they show and narrate, and how they capture what is shown and narrated through drawing. On a second level, the paratextual framings and the memory-historical conditions and goals from which the publications emerged must be discussed—Kantor introduces his book himself and is credited as the author of the publication; Helga Weissová also lives to see the publication of her diaries and drawings. Horst Rosenthal, in contrast, was murdered in Auschwitz, meaning his satirical engagement with the camp experience was published only posthumously. This is also true of the drawings by René Baumer, who survived the Holocaust but never published his works during his lifetime, so that they only appeared as a book after his death when his brother found them in his estate.
Our research will address these two questions and will take up a third question: What role do the drawings of contemporary witnesses play in the development and current constitution of graphic narratives about the Holocaust? Can more or less concrete connections be demonstrated between these early depictions and Holocaust comics like Spiegelman’s Maus, Ari Richter’s Never Again Will I Visit Auschwitz: A Graphic Family Memoir of Trauma and Inheritance (2024), Michel Kichka’s Deuxìeme generation – Ce que je n’ai pas dit à mon pere (2012), or Amy Kurzweil’s Flying Couch: A Graphic Memoir? (2016). Do artists today draw upon these sketches, and how can they be located within the dense, cross-media web of Holocaust documents?
See Daniel Stein, “Never Again and Again and Again: Towards a Cross-Generational Genealogy of Graphic Holocaust Depiction,” in: Mikota, Jana, Daniel Stein und Jens Aspelmeier (Hg.): Grafisches Erzählen über den Holocaust: Theorie, Analyse, Anwendung. Siegen: Universi. In preparation.