Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Aborted access to civic engagement

A qualitative study using the example of people with a migration background in German charitable organizationsTitle of the project

In the project funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG) entitled "Aborted access to civic engagement. A qualitative study using the example of people with a migration background in German welfare organizations", the question of the significance of social differences in the drop-out process was investigated using the example of people with a migration background who have broken off their involvement in welfare organizations as organizations of the German majority society.

Studierende in der Stadt

Project description

Due to the publicly postulated increase in the importance of civil society, civic engagement is becoming increasingly relevant for social participation. At the same time, socially disadvantaged groups and minorities are underrepresented in this engagement. While there is a great deal of research on the uptake of civic engagement, there is hardly any research on the drop-out. Similarly, engagement research focuses largely on individual motives, while there are few studies on how the respective field of engagement and socially shared patterns of interpretation shape the course of engagement. The aim of the research project was therefore to reconstruct the processes that lead to the discontinuation of civic engagement. The question of the significance of social differences in the termination process was investigated using the example of people with a migration background who have terminated their involvement in charities as organizations of the German majority society. The termination was understood in connection with and as the end of an access process. Access and discontinuation processes were researched as a socially produced reality in the interaction between the environment of engagement and those interested in engagement. For this reason, the perspective of individual volunteers who have discontinued their involvement was compared with that of groups of actively involved volunteers. The former was collected via topic-centered narrative interviews, the latter via group discussions.

A key finding of the research project is that the discontinuation processes described are significantly influenced by the specific field of volunteering in welfare work and the specific activities carried out in it. Here, those involved have experiences that bind them to the commitment in a special way, as well as those that repel them from the commitment: On the one hand, care and assistance enable special interpersonal relationships. On the other hand, welfare is characterized by economization, which is met with opposition and rejection by those involved. Discontinuation processes in the field of welfare are therefore characterized by a particular tension.

The analysis of the significance of migration, on the other hand, has shown that Topics associated with migration and migration background, such as foreign language skills, difficulties in accessing the labor market and experienced attributions of difference, shape the narratives - however, they are only made relevant by the interviewees for the inclusion of the BE and as positioning in relation to the interviewer. With regard to the dropout processes, the specific experiences in the field of welfare are more relevant.

Everything at a glance

  • Icon Kalender

    Duration
    01.06.2014 - 31.08.2017

  • Icon Tag

    Research area
    Education and Social Affairs

  • Icon Abzeichen Euro

    Funding
    German Research Foundation (DFG)

Team | Publications | Lectures

  • Prof.'in Dr.'in Chantal Munsch, project manager
  • Dr. Andreas Kewes, research assistant
  • Annette Demir-Utsch, Moritz Müller & Anne-Marie Stumpf, student assistants
  • Kewes, Andreas; Munsch, Chantal (2020): Engagement in the field of welfare between resonance and contradiction. In: Research Journal Social Movements, 33(1), pp. 37-50.
  • Kewes, Andreas; Munsch, Chantal (2019): Should I Stay or Should I Go? Engaging and Disengaging. Experiences in Welfare-Sector Volunteering. In: voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 30(5), pp. 1090-1103, http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11266-019-00122-7
  • Munsch, Chantal; Kewes, Andreas (2019): Different than expected. Migration-specific categorizations in narratives about terminated civic engagement. In: Social Passages, 11(1), pp. 99-118.
  • Kewes, Andreas; Munsch, Chantal (2018): "What have you got nice, warm hands". Resonance experiences as stubborn self-education of and on the social in welfare state engagement. In: Journal for Social Pedagogy, 04/2018, pp. 401-421.
  • Kewes, Andreas; Munsch, Chantal (2018): Cancellations of commitment in welfare organizations: What role does a "migration background" play? In: Theresa Hilse-Carstensen, Sandra Meusel & Germo Zimmermann (eds.): Volunteering and social inclusion. Perspectives on two social phenomena in science and practice. Wiesbaden: Springer VS, pp. 27-40.
  • Kewes, Andreas; Munsch, Chantal (2018): (Kein) Widerspruch im Engagement - Beobachtungen zum kritischen Potential bürgerschaftlich Engagierter in Wohlfahrtsverbänden. In: Social Passages, 10(1), pp. 85-104, https://doi.org/10.1007/s12592-018-0284-7
  • Kewes, Andreas (2017): Termination of commitment in welfare work. Searching for, finding and losing a meaningful activity. In: Stephan Lessenich (ed.): Closed Societies - 38th Congress of the German Sociological Association. Vol. 38 (2017): Closed Societies, http://publikationen.soziologie.de/index.php/kongressband_2016/article/view/512
  • "Spaces of experience instead of groupism. On the critique and supplementation of the singularizing discourse on belonging on the basis of research on discontinued civic engagement", 17th International Migration Conference, Olten (CH), 23.06.2017
  • "Abandoned volunteering. Engagierte Migrant_innen zwischen Subjektkonstruktionen, Motivattributionen und Feldbedingungen", conference "Sozial(arbeits)wissenschaftliche Forschung in der Migrationsgesellschaft" at the FH Kiel and the DGS section "Migration und ethnische Minderheiten", Kiel, 11.05.2017
  • "Are ended civic engagements indications of social closures in the field of welfare work?", 38th DGS Congress, Bamberg, 30.09.2016
  • Discussion of the interim results. Workshop with Mareike Alscher, Helmut Bremer, Michael Corsten, Gisela Jakob, Eckhard Priller, Cihan Sianoglu, Dita Vogel; Environmental Center Hanover, 17.06.2016
  • "Welfare state engagement in the migration society", 25th DGfE Congress, Kassel, 15.03.2016
Follow-up project: "Tensions in fields of engagement. A comparison between church communities, sports clubs, environmental initiatives and charities"
Learn more