Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Canon formation and the social imaginary in British children's and young adult literature

Based on political theories of imagination as a social practice that is suitable for the foundation of collective identities, the project intends to make these approaches usable for questions of canon formation in British children's and young adult literature.

Following Charles Taylor, the imaginations of "Europe", "democracy" and "secularism" will initially be examined in sub-projects. In diachronic and synchronic steps, the extent to which these concepts are negotiated in texts of British children's and young adult literature from the 18th century to the present and narrated as the basis for moral orders and social practices will be analyzed. Since, according to Taylor, the aforementioned narrative styles contribute significantly to the formation of a common modern European identity, the project will examine how texts of British children's and young adult literature that are considered canonical participate in the social imaginary of modern Western European cultures.

The project thus aims on the one hand to position children's and young adult literature research within current cultural-theoretical theories with a decidedly political and ethical orientation; on the other hand, it reflects on a cultural functionalization of the concept of canon.

Bücherstapel

Canon formation

Conference proceedings Canon Consitution and Canon Change in Children's Literature
published by Routledge (2017).

Doctoral student Simone Herrmann receives David Almond Fellowship

Simone Herrmann, PhD student and research assistant in English Literature, has been awarded the David Almond Fellowship, a scholarship for research into children's and young adult literature. The fellowship, supported by Newcastle University, UK, and the Seven Stories National Research Centre for Children's Books, will enable her to gain unique insights into the collections of the Seven Stories Archive, which houses manuscripts, letters and original press reviews of acclaimed British children's authors such as M.E. Atkinson and Ursula Moray Williams. During her research visit in early April 2016, she will also have the opportunity to engage with academics and students from Newcastle University about her research project, which focuses on perceptions of individuals and social formation in British children's and young adult novels.


Seminar by Prof. Dr. Anja Müller and Prof. Dr. Matthew Grenby as part of this year's Newcastle Children's Literature Master Class

August 6 - 7, 2015

Prof. Dr. Anja Müller was invited to give a seminar on "What is an archive?" together with Prof. Dr. Matthew Grenby. The seminar took place as part of this year's Newcastle Children's Literature Master Class
on the topic "The Future of the Subject: Archives". The workshops were led by a team of distinguished international scholars in the field of children's literature research. The participants consisted of a number of excellent international Master's students and PhD students alike.

Doctoral Colloquium between Homerton College and the University of Siegen

May 15, 2015 in Cambridge under the direction of Prof. Maria Nikolajeva and Prof. Dr. Anja Müller


Cambridge


Reading with children's book author and comic artist Marcia Williams

November 03, 2014 at 6 pm, Siegen University Library

Exhibition: Between Trenches and Bond Street: The First World War in German and British Literature

October 13 to November 03, 2014, Foyer of the Siegen University Library

Between the Trenches and Bond Street - The First World War in German and British Literature documents the results of a joint project seminar by students of English and German Studies, which took place at the University of Siegen in the winter semester 2013/14. The exhibition explores forms of representation, remembrance and commemoration of the First World War from the early past to the recent present with reference to exemplary moments in British and German literature. One hundred years after the outbreak of war, the exhibition was presented for the first time in February 2014 in the Siegen City Library. The diverse documents of literary and media commemoration are currently on display at Siegen University Library. A central interest of the project is the integration of complex and often neglected perspectives. We are therefore particularly pleased to announce the visit of the British children's book author and illustrator Marcia Williams, whose work focuses on children's views of the war. The author will read passages from her works, with a special focus on her fictional scrapbook Archie's War. The reading marks a highlight and at the same time the conclusion of the project work.


Canon Constitution and Canon Change in Children's Literature

11-13.09.2014; Prof. Dr. Anja Müller together with apl. Prof. Dr. Bettina Kümmerling-Meibauer (Tübingen); supported by the Fritz Thyssen Foundation - to the website

Canon Constitution and Canon Change in Children's Literature

International Conference at the University of Tübingen, Germany, 11-13 September 2014


Whereas children's classics and their adaptations and transformations into other media have been widely discussed, the history of canonization processes in children's literature in general and the development of a canonical theory of children's literature in particular still need further exploration. Although several scholars have already investigated how national canons of children's literature have developed, such historical approaches have mostly focused on aesthetic matters or on changing concepts of childhood. The impact of cultural concepts that are constitutive for the construction of cultural identities (so-called social imaginaries) on canon formation has, on the other hand, been widely neglected. The same applies to a transnational perspective on canon constitution, which transcends national boundaries and instead locates children's literature in a more comprehensive communicative space. Issues that might be investigated in this respect are the presentations of children's literature in literary histories, the historical contingency of the status of canonicity, the impact of social institutions and awards on the appreciation of certain types of children's literature, the possible reasons for excluding or including particular children's books from/into the canon, the conceptual shifts in the acknowledgement of children's literature in national canons, the influence of genre preferences for canon constitution and the perception of a canon of children's literature as a transnational phenomenon.

 

Thursday, September 11, 2014

9.15-10.00 Registration

10.00-10.30 Opening of the Conference
Welcome Address Prof. Dr. Jürgen Leonhardt, Dean of the Faculty of Philosophy of Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen
10.30-11.30 Keynote Lecture I (Chair: Bettina Kümmerling-Meibauer)
Yael Darr: Nation building and the literary canon for children: The test-case of the Israeli canon for children

Coffee Break 11.30-11.45

Section I: Theoretical Considerations I (Chair: Anja Müller)

11.45-12.15 Helene Høyrup: The cultural capital of canon formation: Some principles for the study of children's literature
12.15-12.45 Bettina Kümmerling-Meibauer: Canon and avant-garde - a paradoxical relationship

Lunch: 12.45-14.00

Section II: Theoretical Considerations II: Project Presentation (Chair: Bettina Kümmerling-Meibauer)

14.00-14.20 Anja Müller: Canon Formation and Social Imaginaries in British Children's Literaure
14.20-14.40 Simone Herrmann: Changing Democratic Values in Nineteenth- and Twentieth-Century Robinsonades for
Children: A Case Study
14.40-15.00 Franziska Burstyn: Of Water-Fairies and the North Wind - Divine Mentorship in Victorian Fantasy Literature

Coffee Break 15.00-15.30

Section III: Changing Criteria in Canonization: Case Studies from Eastern Europe (Chair: Maria Nikolajeva)

15.30-16.00 Dorota Michulka: On valuable, desired, proper and useful books: Children's literature canon(s) in Polish education
16.00-16.30 Anna Czernow: The path of forgetting: Historical twists and turns in the Polish canon of children's literature
16.30-17.00 Svetlana Kalezić-Radonjić: Changing criteria for canonicity - the case of Montenegrin's children's novels

Friday, September 12, 2014

8.45-9.30 Registration

9.30-10.30 Keynote Lecture II (Chair: Anja Müller)
Kimberley Reynolds: Firing the canon! Geoffrey Trease's campaign for an alternative children's canon in 1930's Britain

Coffee Break 10.30-11.00

Section IV: Falling Out of the Canon (Chair: Kimberley Reynolds)

11.00-11.30 Jana Mikota: Communist children's literature, or Canonization and de-canonization in twentieth-century Germany
11.30-12.00 Etti Gordon Ginzburg, M.A.: Women's nonesense vs. literary nonesense: Genre, gender and canon formation -
The case of Laura E. Richards
12.00-12.30 Alison Waller: Remembering, rereading, and reviewing the canon: The case of The Secret Garden and forgotten fiction

Lunch: 12.30-14.00

14.00-15.00 Keynote Lecture III (Chair: Bettina Kümmerling-Meibauer)
Maria Nikolajeva: Digital canons

Coffee Break 15.00-15.30

Section V: The Impact of Institutions (Chair: Yael Darr)

15.00-15.30 Helma van Lierop-Debrauwer: Finally coming together? The bridging role of adolescent literature
15.30-16.00 Erica Hateley: Visions and values: The Children's Book Council of Australia's prizing of picture books in the
twenty-first century
16.00-16.30 Anne Morey: The Junior Literary Guild and the making of new canonical works
19.00 Conference dinner

Saturday, September 13, 2014

Section VII: Canonizing Authors (Chair: Peter Hunt)
9.30-10.00 Sara van den Bossche: The perks of being talked about: On patterns in the canonization processes involving
Astrid Lindgren's works in the Low Countries
10.00-10.30 Michael Düring: Canon formation in the Soviet Union: The case of Swift as author of a children's classic

Coffee Break 10.30-11.00

11.00-12.00 Keynote Lecture IV (Chair: Anja Müller)
Peter Hunt: The case of canons and classics: The impossibility of definitions?
12.00-12.30 Final Discussion

Please return your registration by e-mail to:

bettina.kuemmerling-meibauer@uni-tuebingen.de

AND
am.englit-si@muelleranja.eu



Registration Deadline: 31 May 2014

The conference venue is "Schloss Hohentübingen" (a castle on top of the historic center of Tübingen). First documented in 1078, it has become one of Europe's largest archeological university museums.

How to find the conference room:

When crossing the main entrance to the castle, you will arrive on the first courtyard. Please turn to the right. There is an entrance to the Institute of Classical Archeology. Take the spiral staircase up to the second floor. You will enter the institute's foyer. The conference will take place in room no. 165 (the so-called round tower room).

If you are unsure how to get to the Castle Hohentübingen, either from the central station or your accomodation, please check our Travel Information
section.

Further Information:

Tourist information (ENG)

Museum information (DEU)

The closest accommodation to the venue is Hotel Hospiz. It is a 2 minutes walk (about 150 m) from the Castle Hohentübingen.

For further information, please check the website of the Tourist Information

Here is a selection of links to further accommodations close to the venue:

Airports

The nearest airport to Tübingen is Stuttgart Airport, but it is also possible to fly to Frankfurt International Airport (especially for those coming from outside Europe). From Stuttgart airport there is a shuttle service called "Airport Sprinter" going to Tübingen, from Frankfurt International Airport there is a direct and fast connection to Stuttgart central station, where passengers have to change to a regional train going to Tübingen.

  • via Frankfurt International Airport
    There is a long distance train going from Frankfurt International Airport to Stuttgart central station. You will find the platforms on the lower levels of the airport. Please check the timetable on the website of the "Deutsche Bahn"
    (ENG). Please insert: Frankfurt (M) Flughafen (departure) and Tübingen HBF (arrival). You have to change at Stuttgart central station to a regional train going to Tübingen (from a different platform). The travel approx. takes 2-2 1/2 hours.

  • via Stuttgart Airport
    There is the shuttle service "Airport Sprinter" going to Tübingen central station. The service usually runs twice an hour. Please find the timetable here
    (DEU) or on their website
    (DEU). The travel approx. lasts one hour. The fare is 5,95€.

Getting to ...

Getting around in Tübingen

 

Brief description

Based on political theories of imagination as a social practice that is suitable for the foundation of collective identities, the project intends to make these approaches usable for questions of canon formation in British children's and young adult literature. Following Charles Taylor, the imaginations of "Europe", "democracy" and "secularism" will initially be examined in sub-projects. In diachronic and synchronic steps, the extent to which these concepts are negotiated in texts of British children's and young adult literature from the 18th century to the present and narrated as the basis for moral orders and social practices will be analyzed. Since, according to Taylor, these narrative modes contribute significantly to the formation of a common modern European identity, the project will examine how texts of British children's and young adult literature that are considered canonical participate in the social imaginary of modern Western European cultures. The project thus aims on the one hand to position children's and young adult literature research within current cultural-theoretical theories with a decidedly political and ethical orientation; on the other hand, it reflects on a cultural functionalization of the concept of canon.

While recent literary and cultural theory has increasingly focused on the subject's capacity for action and autonomy (key points would be agency and the ethical turn), the active, creative potential of children and young people as cultural agents has so far only been given rudimentary consideration in children's and young adult literature research. What is more characteristic of current YL research is an argumentation within the literary field. The innovative potential of YL is analyzed, for example, in relation to other literary genres, but not in relation to cultural practices (see Reynolds 2007). Another characteristic of YL research is an individualizing perspective that describes the potential for action or "agency" in terms of the private actions of an individual (usually represented by characters) instead of also understanding them as collective orders or shared social practices.

This inner-literary orientation (often linked to the attempt to enhance the status of children's literature in the literary field) also characterizes discussions on canon formation in children's and young adult literature. Although canonicity was discussed in connection with its cultural functionalization in the course of canon criticism in the 1990s, such a link has not yet been established in YL research. The concept of the imaginary as a social practice, which simultaneously serves the construction of collective identities (see Castoriadis, Anderson, Appadurai or Taylor), can be applied to questions of canon formation: Texts that are considered constitutive of a national or transnational canon have shared ideas not only regarding aesthetic values but also regarding a collective cultural self-image. If we attribute a central role within the enculturation process to YCL, it makes sense to examine YCL texts (or so-called classics) that are considered canonical for their representation of shared social orders that are supposed to determine social action. Accordingly, a historical change in the canon could be explained by the historical contingency of the social imaginary in which a literary canon participates. This perspective of investigation would clearly go beyond the distinction proposed by Hans Heino Ewers between timeless "traditional texts", which are passed on from generation to generation and represent a timeless image of childhood, and time-dependent "key texts", which characterize a particular epoch and serve to understand childhood in that time (cf. Ewers 2007). On the one hand, the texts are not determined solely by their reference to concepts of childhood; on the other hand, the coincidence of epoch and idea/concept implied in Ewers' pair of terms is broken up by the fact that a multidimensional concept of social orders takes the place of a purely temporal orientation.

The state of research outlined so far gives rise to the following desiderata in KJL research, which the planned project seeks to address: What is needed is an expansion of the theoretical spectrum in KJL research, particularly with regard to politically oriented approaches. The extensive focus on the actions of the private individual and the only hesitant inclusion of public and, above all, political questions and theories in YL research can be explained by a lack of dissociation of theoretical-critical reflection on YL from intended concepts of childhood. Here, YL research seems to reproduce patterns of the childhood concept of modern societies (separation of family and public sphere; location of the child in the non-public space of the family; individualization; criterion of 'child-appropriateness'), although as a critical meta-discourse it should not necessarily adopt the mechanisms of its subject, but rather distinguish itself from them.

With regard to the question of canon formation, a cultural functionalization of the concept of canon is a desideratum that the present project aims to address. By situating YL in a broader cultural field, the restriction of YL to a purely aesthetic-literary space is simultaneously counteracted. If, within the framework of educational science considerations, a significant share of enculturation processes is conceded to YL, the critical analysis of YL in broader cultural contexts and with the aid of cultural studies methods is logically necessary.

The project's linking of questions of canonicity and canon formation with theoretical considerations on the so-called 'social imaginary' from political theory pursues several objectives of a substantive, theoretical, methodological and structural nature. The most important aim is to locate questions of canonicity and canon formation in a broader cultural or cultural-political context than has been discussed to date in YA research in the context of aesthetic value discussions or reception- and market-oriented studies. The extent to which the chosen approach is suitable for describing and justifying historical canon developments will be tested. In addition, synchronous cross-sections will help to position the exemplarily selected British KJL within European KJL. Through the comparative approaches envisaged in the project via cooperation, a first step will also be taken towards a comparative appreciation of cultural work, especially British YCL, in the context of the construction of European cultural identities.

Specifically, these aims will be elaborated on the basis of three exemplary concepts that Charles Taylor identified as fundamental to the social imaginary of modern Western European societies: Democracy, secularism and Europe. This gives rise to the internal structure of the project with three sub-projects, each of which initially examines the question of which social orders are negotiated in the texts and to what extent Young Adult literature can be said to participate in the social imaginary. While the historical analysis will primarily look for relationships between the development of the cannon and historical change in the social imaginary, the analyses of contemporary literature will focus on the positioning of Great Britain in the European context and the question of how corresponding social practices are negotiated in British YA.

The outlined topic of the project is dealt with in three sub-areas. In each sub-area, a historically oriented question is pursued as well as a synchronous section that focuses on contemporary literature. The three sub-areas are based on the concepts described by Appadurai and Taylor as central narrative modes ("narrative modes"; Taylor 2004, 175ff) for the social imaginary of modern Western European societies: Democracy, secularism, Europe. In the following, the implications of the concepts according to Taylor are presented before the questions of the sub-projects are derived from them.

Management

 

Prof. Dr. Anja Müller

email anja.mueller@anglistik.uni-siegen.de
Image removed.

Research profile
  • English literature and culture of the 18th, 20th and 21st centuries
  • Contemporary drama in English
  • Constructions of childhood in English literature and culture from the Renaissance to the Present
  • Children's literature and literature for young adults
  • Constructions of Identity (esp. Age, Europe)
  • Intertextuality, intermediality and adaptation
  • Political Theory and Literature

Research assistants

Doctoral students

Franziska Burstyn, M.A.

Email
burstyn@anglistik.uni-siegen.de
Image removed.
External Website http://uni-siegen.academia.edu/FranziskaBurstyn
Research profile
  • Children's and Young Adult Literature
  • Victorian Children's Literature
  • (Literary) Nonsense
  • Literature and Food
  • Folklore Theatre and Culture
  • Folk and Fairy Tales

Simone Herrmann, M.A.

E-mail
herrmann@anglistik.uni-siegen.de
Image removed.

External Website
https://uni-siegen.academia.edu/SimoneHerrmann
Research profile
  • Children's literature
  • Fantastic literature
  • Robinsonades/adventure literature
  • the novel in the eighteenth- and nineteenth-century
  • (Neo-)Victorianism
  • Shakespearean drama
  • the graphic novel

Auxiliaries

  • Anna Rick
  • Eva Richard
  • Lena Bültermann

Lectures

The Fickle Fate of Classics (summer semester 2014 / Thursdays, 8.00-10.00)

Prof. Dr. Anja Müller

Workshops

Workshop with Prof Dr. Matthew O. Grenby, Newcastle University

Friday, June 14, 2013

Past conferences

Canon Constitution and Canon Change in Children's Literature, Tübingen

11-13.09.2014; organized by Prof. Dr. Anja Müller together with apl. Prof. Dr. Bettina Kümmerling-Meibauer (Tübingen); supported by the Fritz Thyssen Foundation

Image removed.
Image removed.
Image removed.

Past lectures

Lecture at the Universitá Ca' Foscari

17.11.2015, Venice, Italy

Presentation at the 2015 ISSCL Conference "Constructing Childhoods and Texts for Children"

10-11.04.2015, Dún Laoghaire, Ireland

  • Simone Herrmann:"Robinson Crusoe's Neglected Centuries: 20th- and 21st-Century Transformations of the British Robinsonade."

Presentations at the student conference "Lions and Unicorns"

09-10.02.2015, Siegen

  • Franziska Burstyn: "The Secularization of the Unicorn: From Christ Figure to Cyber-Goddess."
  • Anja Müller, Keynote Lecture: "Mad, Bad and Dangerous to Know, or The Pride of the Rock? Exploring the Symbolic Den ofthe Lions of Lannister."

Invited lecture for the workshop "Transformations of Childhoods in Contemporary Britain"

07-08.11.2014, Bielefeld

  • Anja Müller: "Writing plural childhoods (?) - Some thoughts concerning the recent shortlists of some children's books awards."
  • Also: Response to the lecture "Trnsformations in nursery care for Britain's under-fives c. 1960-2010" by Angela Davis (Warwick)

Lecture at the Inklings Symposium "Dark Visions: Margaret Atwood's Imaginative Travels into the Regions of the Uncomfortable"

27-28.09.2014, Düren

  • Franziska Burstyn: "The North and the Pursuit of the World Song in Russell Hoban's Soonchild."

Lectures at the conference "Canon Constitution and Canon Change in Children's Literature"

11-13.09.2014, Tübingen

  • Anja Müller: "Canon Formation and Social Imaginaries in British Children's Literature."
  • Simone Herrmann: "Changing Democratic Values in Nineteenth- and Twentieth-Century Robinsonades for Children: A Case Study."
  • Franziska Burstyn: "Of Water-Fairies and the North Wind - Divine Mentorship in Victorian Fantasy Literature."

Lecture at the conference "Informing the Inklings - George MacDonald and the Victorian Roots of Modern Fantasy"

13-15.08.2014, Magdalen College Oxford

  • Franziska Burstyn: "A Floating Princess and a Fallen Star, or Gravity Unhinged: Femininity in George MacDonald's and Neil Gaiman's Fiction."

Lecture at the conference "Adventures in Wonder Worlds - The Power of Literary Fantasy"

05.-06.12.2013 Ateneo Veneto, Venice - to the flyer

  • Anja Müller: "Power in/of Fantasy in the Wonder Worlds of J.R.R. Tolkien and G.R.R. Martin."

Lectures at the conference "Born Happy: Happiness, Childhood and Children's Literature"

16.11.2013, St. Hilda's College, Oxford - External link

  • Franziska Burstyn: "Dreaming of the Land of Plenty: A Defense of Utopias in Children's Literature."
  • Simone Herrmann: "'Uninterrupted Harmony' or Barbaric Wasteland: The Ambigious Island Motif in Nineteenth-Century Robinsonades for Children."

Lecture at the conference "'... so that I wished myself to be a horse': The horse as a representative of cultural change in systems of thought"

14-16.11.2013, University of Vechta

  • Anja Müller: "The Different Faces of War Horse - Media Change and Cultural Implications.

Lectures at the conference "Feast or Famine: Food in Children's Literature"

09.11.2013, Roehampton University, London - external link

  • Franziska Burstyn: "The Myth of the Magic Porridge Pot: Never-ending Edibles in Children's Literature."
  • Simone Herrmann: "The Island that Provides - Food Supply and Sustenance in Victorian Robinsonades for Children and Young Adults."

Responsible for content

Prof. Dr. Anja Müller

Faculty of Arts and Humanities
University of Siegen
Seminar for English Studies
Adolf-Reichwein-Str. 2
57068 Siegen

anja.mueller@anglistik.uni-siegen.de

Technically responsible

Kai Hilpisch, M.A.

Faculty of Arts and Humanities
University of Siegen
Adolf-Reichwein-Str. 2
57068 Siegen

hilpisch@phil.uni-siegen.de

Project management

Funding bodies and cooperation partners

The project was funded by the DFG,

Further links

Website of the DFG